Crazy Eyes Charters Customer Reviews

Name: Crazy Eyes Charters
Brand: Crazy Eyes Charters
Rating: 5 (18 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 18
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Rick Phillips and First Mate Nicole consistently put anglers on Lake Erie walleye and perch, with customers regularly catching their limits in 3.5-4 hours. Their well-equipped boat comes stocked with everything needed for a successful day, including rare bathroom accommodations that guests especially appreciate. Rick's expertise in finding fish locations and Nicole's skilled assistance create an efficient team that delivers impressive catches for both experienced anglers and complete beginners. Customers love Rick's playful personality and "saucy banter" with Nicole that creates a fun, relaxed atmosphere on the water. First-time charter guests feel immediately comfortable, with many mentioning how Rick and Nicole make them "feel like part of the crew." Kids as young as 11 successfully reel in some of the day's biggest fish with their patient guidance. Repeat bookings are common, with families already planning return trips and customers specifically recommending Crazy Eyes Charters to other Lake Erie anglers.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Walleye

Limit

Well-Equipped

Knowledgeable

Relaxed

Family-Friendly

Repeat-Bookings

Lake-Erie

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

A group of 7 people fishing in an unknown location

A lone angler on the water, fishing in an unknown location

Twelve fish caught while fishing at an unknown location

Five big fish caught during a fishing trip

Six people fishing at an unknown location

Most Reviewed Trip

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Melissa Komarek

July 14, 2025

Trip - Professional Angler Walleye Fishing Charter Lake Erie on July 14, 2025

6:00 AM - 12:00 PM

We had such a fantastic time fishing on Lake Erie with Captain Rick and his First Mate, Nicole on 7/11/25 and Crazy Eyes Charters. The boat was clean, stocked and prepared for everything we could possibly need for the day. This was my first fishing charter, but I’m told we were even lucky enough to have bathroom accommodations, if necessary, which is rare to find on a charter boat. That alone counts for big points towards what I call customer satisfaction👍🏻 The crew made an excellent team, had a great relationship with saucy banter between them and our captain didn’t waste all his orneriness on his first mate, he had plenty to share with his charter guests which really made for a fun, playful day catching fish. Rick put us on the Walleye and we caught our limit of nice big fish in about 3.5-4 hours. Will definitely book with them again and highly recommend you check them out if you are looking for a great charter experience on Lake Erie. Thanks Nicole and Rick!🎣

Was this helpful ?

John Mcgee

November 20, 2023

Trip - Lake Erie Perch Fishing Charter on November 20, 2023

6:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Captain Rick and First Mate Nicky are the best on Lake Erie!!!!!! Top notch when it comes to catching walleye and perch!!!!!!

Was this helpful ?

Vicki Vaden

November 6, 2023

Trip - Professional Angler Walleye Fishing Charter Lake Erie on November 6, 2023

6:00 AM - 12:00 PM

First time on a charter fishing boat! Great experience was had by all! Thx Crazy Eyes Charters, for making it a fun- filled, memorable day!

Was this helpful ?

Lindsay Vaden

November 6, 2023

Trip - Professional Angler Walleye Fishing Charter Lake Erie on November 6, 2023

6:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Awesome Charter! Nicole and Rick know how to find the fish and bring in the big ones! Book your next charter with them!

Was this helpful ?

Mallory Elling

November 6, 2023

Trip - Lake Erie Perch Fishing Charter on November 6, 2023

6:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Great time fishing!! Caught our limit! They are both very knowledgeable and a good time!! The first mate was excellent!! She knew how to fish! Definitely will be fishing again! #fish-on

Was this helpful ?

Andrew S.

October 1, 2023

Trip - on October 1, 2023

Crazyeyes Charter and Captain Rick provided us with an unforgettable fishing experience. The crew was skilled, the boat was well-equipped, and the adventure was top-notch. We caught some amazing fish and made memories that will last a lifetime!

Was this helpful ?

Lorenzo J.

June 20, 2023

Trip - on June 20, 2023

We had an incredible time with Crazyeyes Charter and Captain Rick. Their expertise in Lake Erie fishing is unmatched, and their dedication to ensuring we had a fantastic trip was evident from start to finish. Highly recommended!

Was this helpful ?

Robert C.

May 30, 2023

Trip - on May 30, 2023

Captain Rick and the team at Crazyeyes Charter know how to make a fishing trip special. The boat was comfortable, the fishing gear top-notch, and their knowledge of Erie walleye fishing was impressive. We had a blast and can't wait to go back.

Was this helpful ?

James B.

May 23, 2023

Trip - on May 23, 2023

Crazyeyes Charter and Captain Rick delivered on their promise of an action-packed fishing adventure. From the moment we stepped on the boat, we knew we were in good hands. If you're looking for a great time on Lake Erie, look no further!

Was this helpful ?

Sean W.

January 6, 2023

Trip - on January 6, 2023

Our day with Crazyeyes Charter and Captain Rick was fantastic. The fishing experience was exceptional, and the crew's friendliness made it even better. We came back with some great catches and a lot of smiles!

Was this helpful ?

Tonja Norris Buns r

July 4, 2022

Trip - on July 4, 2022

Rick had my kids and grandkids out there July 2nd. They can’t stop talking about how much fun they had. Thanks Rick

Was this helpful ?

Ballsack Johnson

October 10, 2021

Trip - Weekend Walleye Fishing Charter Lake Erie on October 10, 2021

6:00 AM - 12:00 PM

My first time charter fishing, or fishing from a boat, or with people who knew how to fish, and I had a great time, and would definitely do it again! They make it super easy, and we had 11 year old kids reeling in some of the biggest catches of the day🤣 Both Rick and Nikki (hoping I remembered their names correctly, and hoping they forgive me for misspelling them) were extremely nice, easy going, and willing to answer all my odd questions on the trip.

Was this helpful ?

Top Lake Erie Fishing Charter

Customer Testimonials for Crazy Eyes Charter in Marblehead

Guests consistently share how memorable their Lake Erie fishing trips are with Crazy Eyes Charter, praising both the trip quality and Captain Rick’s unmatched expertise. Many reviews highlight successful days of walleye and perch fishing, with anglers reeling in impressive catches and enjoying the well-maintained boat and top-tier gear. Families, first-time anglers, and seasoned fishermen alike mention how easy and enjoyable their guided fishing trip was, often noting that they can’t wait to return. These positive Marblehead fishing charter reviews show why so many customers come back year after year.

The feedback also emphasizes the personal touch that sets Crazy Eyes Charter apart. From knowing the best Lake Erie fishing spots to tailoring each trip to meet customer goals, Captain Rick ensures every outing is both fun and productive. Repeat customers regularly mention not only the fish they caught but also the memories made with friends and family on the water. See what others are saying and book your Lake Erie fishing trip with Crazy Eyes Charter today!